8/10
The second SF-detective novel featuring the polite robot Daneel Olivaw and the grumpy detective Elijah Baley. Previously in The Caves of Steel (1954), Elijah Baley was forced to accept the off-world robot Olivaw as a partner in an Earth investigation. Now, Baley is forced to travel off-planet to assist Olivaw in solving a murder on the planet Solaria.
This is a story about people with phobias. Detective Baley is agoraphobic, having lived his entire life in over-populated, underground cities and terrified of even standing on the surface of a planet in the open air. The Solarians are the inverse. Living in vast open spaces, their lives are insular and their societies run by robots. They practice extreme social distancing, afraid of germs. The entirety of the human race is divided between these two unhealthy ways of living, but Baley and Daneel Olivaw are bridging the gaps.
I am again surprised by how much Asimov’s “robot” novels are about the nature of future societies and not just about robots. He was truly a civilisation-builder in his writing.
Asimov gives us another possible future of life with robots. On Solaria, people live isolated lives in futuristic luxury, surrounded by robots. Ten thousand robots per person. Elijah Baley is put away in a huge house filled with robots and it is all a bit creepy and mysterious, and no way to conduct an investigation. I liked the mystery and cinematic quality of it. It might even have been the first seed of ideas that 60 years later would lead to films like Ex Machina (2015). Asimov’s writing has notably improved since the early I, Robot (1950) stories.
It is Asimov’s most compelling robot story yet and I liked it a lot. The novel has a tighter focus than its predecessor The Caves of Steel because of this restricted alien environment. There are in fact two main puzzles in the story: that of robot behavior and that of the Solarian society. The mystery of the whodunnit is almost painfully obvious from the start, but the world-building of Solaria is completely engrossing and carries the novel. Also still interesting is how Asimov has set up rules for his robots and then comes up with real-life situations to have them fail. The whole robot series is just full of interesting thought experiments.
I’ll now move on to the final Foundation novels Asimov wrote in the 1980s. Also, I’m trying to think of thought balloons to add to the people on the cover.
I‘ll have to pass. I hated Caves of Steel too much to read a sequel. Early SF is mostly a miss for me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Early SF is an acquired taste I suppose. But Asimov’s not so bad as other writers of the time, like EE Doc Smith. This Asimov book might be my favourite so far. I liked it more than the Foundation novels.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lensmen – I read them as a teen. Wouldn’t do that again 😁 But Space Opera appeals much more to me than detective stories
LikeLiked by 1 person
I tried to read them last year, maybe you saw the review come by, but I just couldn’t handle it. It was too bad. I like detective stories because it forces Asimov to pay more attention to fleshing out his characters. And, a detective story is always a good way to explore a society from the viewpoint of different classes.
LikeLiked by 2 people
That’s a very good point speaking for detective stories. But still, I don’t like them 😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fair enough!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I disliked the Foundation prequels, curious what you’ll make of them… As for this: maybe, someday.
LikeLiked by 1 person
(first a reread of Foundation 1-5)
LikeLike
I actually like these robot novels more than the Foundation novels! 😀 The stories are tighter and the intellectual puzzles seem more interesting. I will be starting Foundation 5 soon. Maybe this spring. After that I will try the first prequel.
LikeLike
Pingback: TOP 100 SCI-FI BOOKS | A Sky of Books and Movies
Pingback: ISAAC ASIMOV. The Naked Sun (1957). | Only Detect
I did enjoy The Naked Sun and The Caves of Steel all those years ago. Wouldn’t mind a reread. Not sure what Asimov would have thought of it, but I love what was done with the movie, The Bicentenniel Man. I think one of Asimov’s contemporaries helped with the script.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I enjoyed Asimov’s robot stories much more than I expected. Asimov was a clever guy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I liked Asimov’s Robot stories too. His fiction was hit and miss but I did enjoy his popular science books. Didn’t read all of them of course. I believe he wrote a hundred and twenty.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Far too many to read them all.
LikeLiked by 1 person
🙂
LikeLike
Pingback: Review: Isaac Asimov – Foundation and Earth (1986) | A Sky of Books and Movies