Review: Prelude to Foundation (1988) by Isaac Asimov


Warning: do NOT make this your first Foundation novel. It will not give a good introduction and will spoil later books for you. Please start with the original trilogy from the 1950s. Publication order is best.

When Asimov was asked by his publisher to write more Foundation novels, the idea of a prequel would not have been hard to come up with. After all, the first Foundation novel starts at a juncture in time when the great and old mathematician Hari Seldon puts his plan in motion for the establishment of the Foundation, and after that we only see Seldon in short pre-recorded appearances. His name towers over the whole series, but as readers we hardly know anything about him. The same goes for Trantor, the world-covering city where he lived. We never really see it in its heyday except for a short chapter at the beginning of the series. A Foundation prequel therefore offers tremendous opportunities for interesting storytelling and world-building. 

So, how does Asimov take up these opportunities?

Set 30 years before the start of Foundation (1951), young academic Hari Seldon is called to the Emperor Cleon I to explain about his theory of psychohistory. The theory is merely a theoretical idea, a brainstorm, and Seldon doesn’t believe it has any practical value at all, to the chagrin of the Emperor. He is dismissed, only to get pursued by competing agencies trying to get their hands on him. Seldon as a character is… pretty much the same as every other Asimov character. It’s hard to describe him past his occupation. They all talk the same. But he is young and away from home, (presumably) intelligent and easily influenced. 

The story is a flight from one sector of Trantor to another, showing us facets of the great world city. Seldon is partnered up with a woman, Dors, who looks after him and romantic tension increases between them. Meanwhile, Seldon is wracking his brain to find a way to make psychohistory practicable, while mystery deepens about the motivations of those who help him and who are after him. If I lay it out like this, it sounds more exciting than it actually is to read. Asimov is not much of a thriller writer. The dialogues are all a bit long-winded and tension is not cultivated in the text. And what about the world-building? Some of the Trantor cultures have a Jack Vancian flavour to them but lack Vance’s sardonic wit. Asimov’s rational, analytical tone conveys no flavour of mood. The world-building is inserted in patches whenever Hari and Dors move around, and none of it really bowls me over. 

The two Foundation sequels (Foundation’s Edge (1982) and Foundation and Earth (1986)) were an opportunity for Asimov to tie this universe to the robot novels, and no doubt he thought that this prequel offered another opportunity to do so. The way I see it, he sacrificed Hari Seldon’s story to crowbarring in more robot stuff. His story serves to make references to other novels. Although, I also understood that the next book, Forward the Foundation (1992) deals with large parts of Hari’s life, so if we take Prelude as just a… well… a prelude… then it makes sense that the story doesn’t cover much time.

The book is dull. Asimov’s forte is good ideas, but when there are none, then nothing else works out because his characters, prose and plotting are all terribly pedestrian. On top of that, he turns Seldon into an idiot. The motivations he gives Seldon for his idiotic decisions are flimsy and unconvincing. I ended up not liking Seldon and not enjoying his journey.

This entry was posted in Books, Science fiction and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

21 Responses to Review: Prelude to Foundation (1988) by Isaac Asimov

  1. Bookstooge says:

    Yep, for the most part Asimov was a short story guy and he excelled there. Take him out of that format and whammo, no good.
    Wasn’t this the book where they have the “bald” look and some girl pretends to be entranced by Seldon because he has hair? I might be confusing it with another prequel book though. maybe even one of those written by that other author, whose name I can’t remember for the life of me 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes you are correct! This is the book where Seldon wears a skullcap and lets a woman ruffle his hair in a locked booth in exchange for a holy book.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Bookstooge says:

        Ughhh. See, that’s ALL I remember from this book. That’s a pretty damning indictment in my mind.
        Do you think you’ll try more Foundation or are you done?

        Liked by 1 person

        • Did you also forget that he went to the province of moustachioed swarthy men and adopted a street urchin who says things like “Gee lady, you’re a crazy dame, ya know?”

          No, I am done with Foundation. I’ll watch the TV series that is just now coming out, but I’m not getting anything more out of these books.

          Liked by 1 person

          • Bookstooge says:

            I HAD forgotten that. Thank goodness 😉

            I pretend that the Foundation trilogy is all that exists….

            Liked by 1 person

            • A few years ago I bought the entire series for a few euros, so I felt compelled to read them all. But the sequels were so disappointing that I kept kicking the can down the road. Now I can finally set myself free!

              I made the same mistake with EE Doc Smith’s Lensman series. The only time it worked out was when I bought all of Herbert’s Dune novels. But I am extra careful now about buying a whole series before actually trying it out.

              Liked by 2 people

  2. Andreas says:

    I probably won’t read the series at all but watch the Apple TV show instead.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. bormgans says:

    100% agree with your review, well done. I´d rate it only 4 or 5 I guess. I´ll reread 1-5 one day, but these prequels, never again…

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Ola G says:

    OMG, I’m not coming anywhere near that, even with a ten-foot pole. Asimov’s Foundation was pushing it for me; this one I’d probably shred to pieces. Not a fan 😉

    Liked by 1 person

  5. John Schmidt says:

    I think it was an act of literary genius for Asimov to insert Daneel into his Foundation saga. With Daneel in the story, we get to see the construction of the mythical figure of Hari Seldon. Daneel needed a figurehead that would prop-up the First Foundation and provide it with a mythical father figure. Sadly, I did not find Asimov’s depiction of the “world city” Trantor to be a believable depiction of city life in that future age of interstellar space travel, but Asimov was busy fishing for telepathy genes. The story does pick up speed in “Forward the Foundation” with exploration of Wanda’s telepathic powers.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s